Water Heater Repair in New Albany, IN
No hot water? Find the best water heater repair pros in your area.
Floyd County15 plumbers available
Best Water Heater Repair Pros in New Albany
#1Conditional Hire
Pate Plumbing Services
4.7Water Heater Repair: 95/100
“Arrived exactly on time, old unit out and new installed perfectly”
#3Conditional Hire
Overflow Plumbing, LLC
4.9Water Heater Repair: 95/100
“On time and quick repair.”
All Water Heater Repair Pros in New Albany
Pate Plumbing Services
4.7·27 reviews·
In New AlbanyGoogle Verified
+2 more
Solid pick4.7Google
Strengths
Exceptional responsiveness: 4 of 5 reviews explicitly mention…
Transparent, fair pricing: 3 reviews specifically praise…
Repeat customer confidence: One homeowner reports 4 service calls…
Concerns
Severe negative outlier: 1 of 5 reviews (20%) is a 1-star with…
Quality consistency unclear: One 1-star review expresses extreme…
1-Tom-Plumber
4.9·1.4k reviews·
12 mi away — Serves your areaGoogle Verified
+3 more
Solid pick4.9Google
Strengths
Exceptional emergency responsiveness: Multiple reviewers praise…
Consistently excellent workmanship across varied jobs (toilet…
Strong communication and transparency: 6 reviewers explicitly…
Professional crew demeanor: Multiple reviews highlight…
Concerns
Pricing variance: 2 of 8 Yelp reviews (25%) specifically mention…
One review reports technician declined to diagnose clogged sink…
Overflow Plumbing, LLC
4.9·232 reviews·
12 mi away — Serves your areaGoogle Verified
+5 more
Solid pick4.9Google
Strengths
Exceptional next-day or same-day emergency response even on…
Thorough diagnostic approach using camera inspection and…
Named technicians (William, Darian, Rick, Anna, Matt, Noah)…
Competitive pricing on estimates;
Concerns
Significant platform rating discrepancy: Google 4.9/5 (232…
Incomplete job follow-up: 1 review notes baseboards removed…
Norton & Associates Plumbing
4.8·286 reviews·
In New AlbanyGoogle Verified
+4 more
Top pick4.8Google
Strengths
Exceptional responsiveness: 3 of 5 reviews explicitly mention…
No upselling: reviewer specifically praised for being…
Thorough workmanship: 3 reviews highlight careful, complete…
Friendly, personable staff: dispatcher Amy and technicians…
Preliminary listing — full review analysis coming soon
Golden Plumbing
4.8·438 reviews·
8 mi awayGoogle Verified
+5 more
Solid pick4.8Google
Strengths
Emergency responsiveness: 6 reviews explicitly mention same-day…
Pricing competitiveness: 5 reviews praise 'reasonable,'…
Communication and transparency: 7 reviews mention thorough…
Team consistency and professionalism: Jacob Allen, Dean Titus,…
Concerns
Not enough data to identify consistent weaknesses;
Your Second Opinion Plumbing Co.
4.9·286 reviews·
7 mi awayGoogle Verified
+6 more
Top pick4.9Google
Strengths
Emergency responsiveness: 3 of 5 reviews highlight same-day or…
Transparent, fair pricing: 2 reviews explicitly praise quote…
Exceptional workmanship and site conduct: 2 reviews highlight…
Proactive communication: Multiple reviews cite pre-arrival phone…
Preliminary listing — full review analysis coming soon
Blackburn & Davis Inc
3.5·63 reviews·
7 mi awayGoogle Verified
+4 more
Solid pick3.5Google
Strengths
Consistently fair pricing that undercuts larger competitors by a…
Responsive and accessible for troubleshooting.
Professional, kind, and patient technicians.
Strong track record on complex emergency repairs.
Concerns
Project timelines can slip on large jobs.
Dauenhauer Plumbing Heating Air & Electric
4.8·8.9k reviews·
11 mi away — Serves your areaGoogle Verified
+3 more
Solid pick4.8Google
Strengths
Fast emergency response with multiple same-day or next-morning…
High-caliber technical expertise with technicians diagnosing…
Consistently professional and patient technicians who explain…
Strong BBB accreditation with A+ rating and zero complaints in…
Concerns
Installation quality failures with lasting consequences: improper…
Previous AC installation involved missing filter frame never…
Inconsistent communication during delays: one reviewer scheduled…
Pricing inconsistency: charged full price despite two consecutive…
Tony's Plumbing Co Inc
4.5·139 reviews·
7 mi awayGoogle Verified
+4 more
Top pick4.5Google
Strengths
Exceptional pricing fairness: 4 of 5 reviews explicitly praise…
High-quality workmanship and efficiency: 5 of 5 reviews mention…
Excellent customer service and communication: 4 of 5 reviews…
Long-term customer retention: one reviewer reports using Tony's…
Preliminary listing — full review analysis coming soon
Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup
4.6·437 reviews·
7 mi awayGoogle Verified
+3 more
Solid pick4.6Google
Strengths
Exceptional after-hours and emergency responsiveness: Multiple…
High-quality technician workmanship and professionalism: 18+…
Clear communication and customer education: Technicians…
Competitive pricing for complex jobs and willingness to advocate…
Concerns
Incomplete service delivery on record: One review reports…
At least one documented instance of poor customer service and…
After-hours premium pricing can exceed reasonable limits: One…
Inconsistent first-visit problem resolution: One customer…
Avantel Plumber of Louisville KY
5·13 reviews·
8 mi awayGoogle Verified
+5 more
Top pick5.0Google
Strengths
Fast emergency response: Multiple reviewers cite on-site arrival…
Transparent communication and fair pricing: 3 reviewers…
Thorough workmanship: 4 reviewers praise attention to detail, not…
Proven late-night emergency capability: One reviewer specifically…
Preliminary listing — full review analysis coming soon
Noah's Plumbing & Water Heaters
4.8·89 reviews·
14 mi away — Serves your areaGoogle Verified
Proceed with care4.8Google
Strengths
Water-heater service mentioned in 49 of 100 reviews;
Same-day dispatch in 19 of 100 reviews;
Weekend/Saturday dispatch confirmed
Concerns
One reviewer alleges this is a fake Google listing operated by a…
Manager named James Reesor flagged for disrespectful…
Quote-vs-final-bill discrepancy cited
Voicemail-full and no-callback complaints
ASI Plumbing
4.9·2.4k reviews·
11 mi away — Serves your areaGoogle Verified
+4 more
Solid pick4.9Google
Strengths
Same-day or next-day emergency response: 7 reviews explicitly…
Exceptional attention to property cleanliness and…
Upfront pricing transparency: 5 reviews mention upfront…
Clear communication and customer education: 5 reviews highlight…
Concerns
Multiple reports (3 reviews) of misdiagnosis leading to…
Tension between Google 4.9 rating (2389 reviews) and Yelp 3.8…
Management responsiveness red flag: 2 reviews specifically cite…
Warranty/guarantee concerns: 1 review reports being denied return…
St. Matthews Plumbing
4.9·516 reviews·
10 mi away — Serves your areaGoogle Verified
+2 more
Top pick4.9Google
Strengths
Fast_response theme appears in 17 of 80 reviews;
Self-corrected mistakes at no charge
Christmas Eve toilet install completed before the holiday
Concerns
Initial recommendation of a new toilet flagged when augering the…
Benjamin Franklin Plumbing
5·85 reviews·
12 mi away — Serves your areaGoogle Verified
+3 more
Top pick5.0Google
Strengths
Fast_response theme in 17 of 76 reviews;
Pricing transparency cited
After-hours emergency dispatch confirmed
Concerns
Not enough data to identify weaknesses
Common Water Heater Repair Scenarios
No Hot Water
Complete loss of hot water from a tank or tankless unit. Could be a failed heating element, thermostat, or gas valve issue.
Leaking Water Heater
Water pooling around the base of your tank is urgent — it can mean a failing tank that could rupture and flood your home.
Strange Noises or Smells
Popping, banging, or rumbling from your water heater signals sediment buildup. A sulfur smell may indicate a failing anode rod or gas leak.
Water Heater Replacement
Units over 10-12 years old that need frequent repairs are usually better replaced. Modern units are more efficient and reliable.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does water heater repair cost in New Albany, IN?
Water heater repair in New Albany typically costs $150-$500 for common fixes like thermostat or element replacement. Full water heater replacement runs $1,200-$3,500 installed, depending on tank vs tankless and fuel type. Get multiple quotes from plumbers listed below.
Should I repair or replace my water heater?
If your water heater is over 10 years old and needs a repair costing more than $500, replacement is usually the better investment. Newer models are more energy-efficient and come with warranties. Plumbers in New Albany can help you evaluate the best option.
How long does water heater installation take?
A standard tank water heater replacement takes 2-4 hours. Tankless installations can take 4-8 hours due to additional venting and gas line work. Most plumbers in Floyd County can complete same-day installation if the unit is in stock.
Can I get emergency water heater service in New Albany?
Yes — several plumbers serving New Albany offer same-day and emergency water heater repair. A leaking tank is urgent and should be addressed immediately to prevent water damage. Check the plumber ratings below for responsiveness scores.
Other Services in New Albany
Drain Cleaning Burst Pipe Repair Repiping Bathroom Remodel Plumbing Sewer Repair Sewer Line Replacement Toilet Repair Faucet Repair Garbage Disposal Repair Sump Pump Repair Gas Line Repair Slab Leak Repair Water Line Repair Kitchen Remodel Plumbing Hydro-Jetting 24-Hour Plumber Same-Day Plumber Affordable Plumber Licensed Plumber Plumber Cost Clogged Drain No Hot Water Water Leak Low Water Pressure Frozen Pipes Sewage Backup All Emergency Plumbers
Water Heater Repair in Nearby Cities
Need Water Heater Repair Right Now?
Call a top-rated water heater repair pro in New Albany.
Call Top-Rated Pro NowAre You a Plumber?
Get listed on Fast Plumber Near Me and connect with homeowners who need emergency plumbing help right now. Free basic listings available.